Aslı Palaska
Everyone said Mr. Hale is the perfect teacher.
I believed it. Every laugh, every patient explanation, every small miracle of teaching made mistakes feel normal. The chalk dust clung to his fingers like smoke and his voice rolled like warm honey over the hum of the fluorescent lights. Even algebra, confusing as it is, made sense when he explained it. He moved through the room like he could bend time, kneeling beside struggling desks, whispering encouragement, adjusting papers, straightening chairs all with the same quiet authority. For a moment everything outside the classroom, the cold hallways didn’t exist. I knew in that brief golden bubble that nothing terrible could touch me while he was here.
Thursday after school, I lingered around in the library. Mom was late, so I was pretending to read. The hallway outside stretched gray and quiet. That’s when I saw him. A small black cat had slipped into the parking lot, fur all wet from the rain, eyes wide and frantic. Mr. Hale didn’t notice anyone else, he was just tracking the shadow of the cat. He bent quickly. The cat hissed, leaped backwards and then he suddenly stabbed the cat. There was a sharp snap, a thump then silence. The cat laid still, tail twitching only once before going completely limp. He straightened himself, dusted his hands, adjusted his tie and walked on with the now dead cat in his hands. I couldn’t breathe for a long time, I felt like shadows stretched unnaturally, the lot folding in on itself. I wanted to look away from the blood on the concrete ground but something tethered me to not do so at that moment.
The next day he returned to class. Chalk dust on his shirt, soft laughter, lessons rolling on like how they normally do. Yet I started to notice: the stiffness in his shoulders, the way his eyes moved so suddenly on small movements. He had a habit I had realized while following him around. On Tuesdays, he would disappear into the basement after school, carrying a box he never showed anyone. Sometimes when the janitor went by, I saw him return with the box empty. My friends didn’t notice and I didn’t dare to question it. But I could feel the pulse of it…something kept hidden, something that did not belong. Occasionally in long gray afternoons I imagine the lot again: the black cat, the sharp snap and the twitch of the tail. I imagine the box that goes into the basement each Tuesday. I do not speak of it, I only watch. Every word, smile along with every motion of Mr. Hale now feels measured. Something down there waits beneath the surface of the world I thought I knew of. Sometimes, I think it watches me back.
The hallways emptied, the afternoon light slanted through the windows: thin and yellowed. I paused at the bottom of the stairwell feeling the hum of the fluorescent lights in my chest. Somewhere below behind doors that should have led to nothing, something moved or maybe had moved. I couldn’t really tell which. I stepped back, chest tight and swallowed the thought that would not leave me: whatever was down there, whatever he kept hidden, it was waiting and it would not wait forever.